Everton are in the market for a new head coach after parting ways with Sean Dyche. The 53-year-old was dismissed on Thursday, just hours ahead of the Toffees’ FA Cup third-round clash against Peterborough United from League One.
Dyche, who took over from Frank Lampard in January 2023, had managed to keep Everton in the Premier League but leaves the club hovering precariously in 16th place, narrowly above the relegation zone. The decision marks a critical juncture for Everton, who now face the task of identifying a manager to steer them clear of further struggles.
Potential candidates for the role
David Moyes
David Moyes, a familiar figure at Goodison Park, has emerged as a potential option. The Scotsman led Everton for 11 years, overseeing more than 500 matches. During his tenure, Moyes guided the team to consistent top-eight finishes, including a fourth-place finish in the 2004-05 season that earned them a spot in the Champions League qualifiers.
Since leaving Everton to succeed Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United, Moyes has had stints at Real Sociedad, Sunderland, and West Ham United, where he won the Conference League in 2023. At 61, Moyes remains keen to return to management but has stated he is reluctant to take on roles involving relegation battles.
Thomas Frank
Brentford manager Thomas Frank has also been linked with the vacancy. Over the past six years, the 51-year-old has established the Bees as a formidable Premier League side, earning promotion in 2021 via the Championship play-offs. However, with Brentford currently sitting comfortably in 11th place, it remains unclear whether Frank would swap stability for a relegation fight.
Steve Cooper
Steve Cooper is available after being dismissed by Leicester City in November. Despite his short-lived tenure at Leicester, the former Nottingham Forest manager boasts a promotion to the Premier League on his resume. His recent experience of working under pressure in challenging circumstances may make him an intriguing option for Everton’s hierarchy.
High-profile and International prospects
Gareth Southgate
Gareth Southgate, who stepped down as England manager following the Euro 2024 final, is another name in the mix. During his eight-year stint with the national team, the 54-year-old led England to two European Championship finals. However, with limited club management experience and no indication of immediate interest in returning to football, Southgate appears a long shot.
Massimiliano Allegri
Former Juventus boss Massimiliano Allegri has been suggested as a potential candidate. The 57-year-old Italian boasts an impressive managerial record, having won Serie A six times and reached two Champions League finals. Allegri, however, has yet to manage outside Italy, which could present a challenge for both him and Everton.
Other Candidates
Other names reportedly under consideration include Leighton Baines, currently serving as interim manager, and Lee Carsley, who is leading England’s Under-21 team. Additionally, Edin Terzic, who recently left Borussia Dortmund after guiding them to the Champions League final, and Paulo Fonseca, formerly of Lille and Roma, have been mentioned.
What comes next for Everton?
With the January transfer window in full swing and the club precariously positioned in the league table, the appointment of a new manager is a crucial decision for Everton. Their next choice must bring Premier League experience and the ability to stabilize a team in a challenging position. Fans and pundits alike will watch closely as the Toffees chart their path forward.
